"Shared Responsibility" Premium Hike Effective In Ohio Today

Here's how easy it is for the government and the insurance industry to spend your money to solve their problems.

Today, the State of Ohio institutes a 4% increase in the cost of individual (non-group) health plans to subsidize the cost of similar plans for people with pre-existing health conditions.

Ohio insurers are required by law to offer "open enrollment" health plans to indviduals with pre-existing health conditions which might disqualify them from conventional health insurance coverage. The plans are quite costly; individuals covered under the plans spend an average of $800-850 per month for coverage, well over twice what healthier people pay for similar coverage.

The plans are also hard to find. Insurers are required to offer them to the public only one month per year, and there's no standard for informing the public (usually you'll find a box in the classified section).

For both these reasons, not many Ohioans participate in the plan. Only about 1,300 out of Ohio's million or so uninsured residents have signed up for them.

The State budget passed in July sought to create a subsidy for open enrollment participants by assessing a 5% rate increase on all health plans sold in Ohio, including small group health plans. That would have created a huge windfall for insurers who sell non-group plans, in exchange for solving a problem for only a relatively few people.

The Ohio General Assembly eventually abandoned that approach, choosing instead to focus the premium surcharge on individual health plans. (It's not clear that a similar effort to hike small group premiums could have stood up to constitutional review, but individual health plans are at the Legislature's mercy).

So the Ohio Department of Insurance has been given an "oversight" role, to monitor rates and report back to the Governor. Ostensibly, if overall rates in the individual market rise more than 5 1/2%, the Department will scale back on the subsidy for open enrollment plans. Translation: if so many sick people sign up for subsidized coverage that it drives rates up, the Insurance Department will use pricing to slow down the rate at which they sign up.

This is a sign of things to come. When insurers tell legislatures, as they've told the White House, that they'll gladly stop rejecting applicants with pre-existing health conditions as long as everyone must buy health coverage, what they're generally NOT saying is that the cost of that largesse will be paid for by raising rates for everyone else...all in the name of "shared responsibility." But the REAL effect is to provide insurers with a subsidy enabling them to sell more individual health policies. And eventually, the price won't matter, because the law will require everybody to buy a health plan, no matter what it costs.