The White House was all aghast yesterday when a study by PriceWaterhouseCoopers commissioned by America's Health Insurance Plans (AHIP), the insurance industry trade association, suggested that the Senate Finance Committee's health reform bill would raise the price of health insurance 40% more than would be the case under current law.
If you'd like to review the study, here's a link: http://www.americanhealthsolution.org/assets/Reform-Resources/AHIP-Reform-Resources/PWC-Report-on-Costs-Final.pdf
As is usually the case with the debate over health insurance reform, the report is a mixture of worst-case-scenario doomsday predictions...and some inconvenient truth.
The report focuses on four elements of the Finance Committee's bill:
1)...The introduction of insurance market reforms and consumer protections that would raise insurance premiums for individuals and families if the reforms are not accompanied by a universal coverage mandate;
2)...An excise tax on employer-provided high-value health plans ("Cadillac plans")that in a few years could raise premiums on moderate-value plans;
3)...Cuts in payment rates for public health plans which would accelerate cost shifts to the private sector, and;
4)...New taxes on health care entities which would be passed on to consumers.
AHIP's first concern is that a requirement that health plans be guaranteed issue, and that the variation between rates for the youngest and healthiest vs. the oldest and sickest individuals be not more that 4:1, will raise rates for younger people and make it difficult for them to afford coverage, even with generous subsidies.
The organization's stated concern is that if young people aren't able to buy coverage affordably, and aren't required to buy it, they'll wait to purchase coverage until they're sick, and make a mess for everybody. And if you buy the report's analysis, their conclusion is valid.
But I don't buy it for a second.
The industry's interest in a requirement to purchase coverage is the expectation that an individual mandate would create a brand new pool of young, healthy people who'll pay a lot in premiums cumulatively, but won't use their coverage. This is VERY profitable for insurers. That's why insurers are so interested in keeping prices as low as possible for younger people, even if doing so socks it to older folks (okay, like me).
And right now, while most states limit the variations on group insurance premiums (in Ohio, the variation is plus-or-minus 80%), there's currently no limit on the difference between what insurers can charge people in the individual market. And the differences in premium rates can be staggering.
A change to community rating and guaranteed issue would, indeed, raise premium rates for younger individuals; they might pay a little more than insurance industry actuaries would like to charge them. But they also tend to age eventually, and then will benefit from that subsidy.
A 60% increase in my 24-year-old's insurance premiums would raise them from $125 to $200 per month. But as he gets older, the rating reform suggests that his rate wouldn't be more than $800 per month as he got to his 60's.
I think the industry's real fear is that young folks would jump ship from private insurance to an expanded Medicaid program (assuming they earned less than some appropriate multiple of the poverty line), and they'd lose all that revenue.
I want to talk about the two tax-related issues together, so let's focus for a minute on the cost-shifting boogeyman. The industry's concern is that reductions in the growth of spending on Medicare and Medicaid would accelerate a cost shift to the private sector. The report makes no allowance, however, for the possibility that the spending reductions might actually reduce costs and increase efficiencies on the provider side.
It's an unfortunate political truth that spending cuts in health care are almost always specious...often, they're accounting tricks to move expenditures off the books in one year only to restore them in the next year. But AHIP's analysis suggests NO reductions in the rate of spending will occur over the next ten years, and ALL the excess costs will be passed along to a helpless and hapless private sector. Cost shifting is easy to suspect, and hard to prove...not worth the doomsday picture the industry's analysis suggests.
Now the taxes...that's another story...
The Finance Committee has proposed a 40% excise tax on "Cadillac plans"...basically, plans that cost more than $8000/year for one person or $21,000 for a family, regardless of whether the plan is a group plan or a non-group plan. I've said here before that this provision just shows how little our elected officials know about what health insurance costs.
Last year, when I was forced to shop for non-group insurance for my family, the best price I could get, on a plan with a $3000 family deductible, was $1880 per month: more than my mortgage payment, and a whopping $22,560 per year. Sure didn't feel like a Cadillac plan.
A 40% excise tax on that plan would add up to $9024, making the effective cost $31,584. It's an easy-seeming way to raise revenue, but:
...Do we really expect that insurance companies will just eat that nine grand?...Puh-leez!...Insurance companies are like the house in Vegas: they never lose, because they're paying with your money. Somehow, that cost is going to get passed along, and;
2)...Do we really buy the contention that the tax will force employers to buy less generous plans?...Like what...a plan with a $5000 family deductible?...$10,000?...
And while this is being positioned as a go-after-the-rich-guys tax, I suspect a close analysis would conclude that many folks on generous health plans are union workers and government employees, who will fight like tigers to keep from having those plans modified.
Now maybe there are large employers who would like to think the imposition of such an excise tax could be used as a gun to the head to wring concessions out of their workers. But certainly nobody's saying that.
The taxes proposed for drugmakers and equipment manufacturers fall into a similar category. Do our elected officials really expect these industry groups to swallow hard and just absorb these tax hikes? And when customers/patients encounter rising co-pays or deductibles for medication or medical equipment, they encounter then through their health plans, and blame the insurance companies for the higher prices. They walk, fly, and quack like stealth taxes on consumers...let's call them what they are.
Finally, though, even as I suggest that the insurers aren't all wet in their analysis, I point out a little thing nobody's talking about: The change from a complex, medically-underwritten system of insurance to a community-rated, guaranteed-issue system should vastly simplify the business processes for health insurers, which should result in a significant reduction in administrative costs. Add in the efficiencies that could be produced by the development of highly-automated insurance exchanges, and there's a strong possibility that the administrative costs for small group and individual insurance coverage could be cut from 25-40% of premiums to half of that. And a significant reduction in those administrative costs could really "bend the curve" for small businesses and individuals. The effects of reducing and controlling administrative costs actually magnify over time, if purchasers can de-link the cost of administrative costs from medical costs, and build marketing, distribution, and management systems which take advantage of economies of scale.
Of course, AHIP's analysis doesn't anticipate that, either.
Showing posts with label " community rating. Show all posts
Showing posts with label " community rating. Show all posts
Tuesday, October 13, 2009
Thursday, August 13, 2009
More On Young Invincibles...And A Hidden Message
It was published a couple years ago, but New York Magazine produced a terrific article which focused on New York's "young invincibles"...young adults 19-29 years old who choose not to purchase health insurance coverage. A link to the article is here...http://nymag.com/news/features/29723/
NYC is a tough town, and one of the most expensive cities in America in which to get sick. It tends to attract large numbers of young people who try their hands at free-lancing and jobs in the arts. But the stories themselves are typical of young folks everywhere; an estimated one-third of uninsured Americans are reportedly between the ages of 19-29, and working in low-wage jobs which don't provide access to group health coverage. They decide to do without coverage because of its costs, even though they know that they are one serious injury or illness away from financial catastrophe.
But the article also hints at another significant issue: the pricing of health insurance coverage, and how insurance costs are spread across New York's "risk pool."
New York is a "community rating" state, which means that everybody buying a particular health plan pays about the same as anybody else, with no regard to age, gender, geography or other factors.
It's also a "guaranteed issue" state, which means applicants cannot be denied coverage due to pre-existing health conditions. The combination of those two factors makes health insurance premiums in New York among the highest in the country.
So for a "young invincible," health insurance premiums can run as high as $300-500 per month for a decent health plan. But a 50-year-old buying the same plan would pay exactly the same rate. And no one applying for the same health plan will be denied coverage.
Most states, including Ohio, use factors like age, gender, residential zip codes, and other factors to set premium rates, which can vary considerably from the mathematical average rate for a policy. Typically, the variation is plus- or-minus 25% from the average; Ohio permits group plans to vary plus- or minus-50% for group plans, which means that coverage for older employees with health conditions can be twice as high as for younger, healthier employees. Ohio also has no limit on the amount insurers can charge for individual policies (shopping casually, I was offered a rate on an individual policy which was TRIPLE the initial quote), permits insurers to deny coverage for applicants with health conditions.
Ohio insurers have set regulations like this in an effort to make their products more attractive to younger, healthier people, who are extremely profitable to insure because, in general, they use fewer health care services. Young folks in Ohio can buy a decent policy for $125 a month (if they qualify for coverage), but those 50-year-olds can pay a lot more. And anybody applying for group coverage can have their application denied for health reasons.
So average insurance premiums in Ohio tend to LOOK a little lower. But that's because Ohio insurers don't cover everybody. And outside of the Cleveland area, the cost of health care in Ohio is significantly lower than in New York.
Why is this important to the health care debate? Because while New York's average premium rates are higher than the national average (8th-highest in the country, according to America's Health Insurance Plans, the industry's trade group, versus Ohio's rates, which rank 35th in the country), the rates in New York are spread out much more equitably than in Ohio. Young New Yorkers pay a higher-than-average rate for coverage, but benefit from that same subsidy as the get older. This is how insurance is supposed to work.
And at the same time, a MUCH lower percentage of New York health premium goes to cover administrative costs, since New York insurers accept all applicants for any given plan at the same rate, irrespective of health or other factors. This is simply much more efficient than having an army of underwriters evaluating every single application received by the insurer, assessing an underwriting "score" based on a bunch of factors, and setting specific prices based on a complicated formula.
New York's approach also gives folks with insurance the assurance that using their plan won't result in dramatically higher rates, or cancellation of their coverage. Folks with health conditions pay the same as everybody else.
Insurance rates in New York are higher, but everybody qualifies for coverage, irrespective of their health. And a higher percentage of New York premiums goes to cover the cost of health care, and a lower percentage to cover insurer administrative costs.
It should be a foregone conclusion that guaranteeing coverage to everyone will raise the cost of health insurance premiums. That's what the evidence shows. But a community rating process would allocate those costs more equitably throughout the system.
There is very little evidence that complex administrative processes and creative health underwriting benefit the health care system at all. The simpler the process, the higher percentage of premium which is devoted to the cost of care, versus the cost of insurer administration
NYC is a tough town, and one of the most expensive cities in America in which to get sick. It tends to attract large numbers of young people who try their hands at free-lancing and jobs in the arts. But the stories themselves are typical of young folks everywhere; an estimated one-third of uninsured Americans are reportedly between the ages of 19-29, and working in low-wage jobs which don't provide access to group health coverage. They decide to do without coverage because of its costs, even though they know that they are one serious injury or illness away from financial catastrophe.
But the article also hints at another significant issue: the pricing of health insurance coverage, and how insurance costs are spread across New York's "risk pool."
New York is a "community rating" state, which means that everybody buying a particular health plan pays about the same as anybody else, with no regard to age, gender, geography or other factors.
It's also a "guaranteed issue" state, which means applicants cannot be denied coverage due to pre-existing health conditions. The combination of those two factors makes health insurance premiums in New York among the highest in the country.
So for a "young invincible," health insurance premiums can run as high as $300-500 per month for a decent health plan. But a 50-year-old buying the same plan would pay exactly the same rate. And no one applying for the same health plan will be denied coverage.
Most states, including Ohio, use factors like age, gender, residential zip codes, and other factors to set premium rates, which can vary considerably from the mathematical average rate for a policy. Typically, the variation is plus- or-minus 25% from the average; Ohio permits group plans to vary plus- or minus-50% for group plans, which means that coverage for older employees with health conditions can be twice as high as for younger, healthier employees. Ohio also has no limit on the amount insurers can charge for individual policies (shopping casually, I was offered a rate on an individual policy which was TRIPLE the initial quote), permits insurers to deny coverage for applicants with health conditions.
Ohio insurers have set regulations like this in an effort to make their products more attractive to younger, healthier people, who are extremely profitable to insure because, in general, they use fewer health care services. Young folks in Ohio can buy a decent policy for $125 a month (if they qualify for coverage), but those 50-year-olds can pay a lot more. And anybody applying for group coverage can have their application denied for health reasons.
So average insurance premiums in Ohio tend to LOOK a little lower. But that's because Ohio insurers don't cover everybody. And outside of the Cleveland area, the cost of health care in Ohio is significantly lower than in New York.
Why is this important to the health care debate? Because while New York's average premium rates are higher than the national average (8th-highest in the country, according to America's Health Insurance Plans, the industry's trade group, versus Ohio's rates, which rank 35th in the country), the rates in New York are spread out much more equitably than in Ohio. Young New Yorkers pay a higher-than-average rate for coverage, but benefit from that same subsidy as the get older. This is how insurance is supposed to work.
And at the same time, a MUCH lower percentage of New York health premium goes to cover administrative costs, since New York insurers accept all applicants for any given plan at the same rate, irrespective of health or other factors. This is simply much more efficient than having an army of underwriters evaluating every single application received by the insurer, assessing an underwriting "score" based on a bunch of factors, and setting specific prices based on a complicated formula.
New York's approach also gives folks with insurance the assurance that using their plan won't result in dramatically higher rates, or cancellation of their coverage. Folks with health conditions pay the same as everybody else.
Insurance rates in New York are higher, but everybody qualifies for coverage, irrespective of their health. And a higher percentage of New York premiums goes to cover the cost of health care, and a lower percentage to cover insurer administrative costs.
It should be a foregone conclusion that guaranteeing coverage to everyone will raise the cost of health insurance premiums. That's what the evidence shows. But a community rating process would allocate those costs more equitably throughout the system.
There is very little evidence that complex administrative processes and creative health underwriting benefit the health care system at all. The simpler the process, the higher percentage of premium which is devoted to the cost of care, versus the cost of insurer administration
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
