One of the potential casualties of health insurance reform, and of the development of state health insurance exchanges, will be the health plans sponsored by chambers of commerce, trade associations, and professional groups. The inefficiencies, greed, and laziness of these plans and their sponsors make them particularly vulnerable as states experiment with the implementation of electronic marketplaces which might operate more efficiently than the traditional ways of marketing and selling health plans. Some of these groups see the change coming, and are trying to adapt. Most have their heads...in the sand...and pray daily that things will turn out all right. Things probably won't...not for the associations, and not for their members.
I got some interesting feedback from my last entry, in which I wrote about the head of a prominent Chamber of Commerce health plan, who has a conflict of interest because of his participation on the panel crafting regulations for Ohio's health insurance exchange.
I raised the conflict because the Chamber receives about $15 million in commissions and other fees from the insurer whose products the Chamber endorses. My point was that the organization's financial dependency on those fees (which comprise about 75% of its budget) made it unlikely that the Director's decision-making would be focused on the best interests of his organization's members.
I also observed that, rather than freeing the Ohio exchange to become more cost-effective and efficient to help reduce the cost of small group health insurance, his incentive would be to preserve his organization's income stream by assuring that the exchange could NOT operate in a way which might reduce costs (and therefore prices) for exchange participants.
Sure enough, that task force produced a recommendation that premium rates for small businesses both inside and outside the exchanges HAD to be the same. So I asked: if the people who are supposed to be representing the interests of small businesses at such tables have sold out, who WILL speak for small business?
I received some calls and e-mails from people who recognized the guy I was talking about. The correspondents all assured me that he was a splendid fellow, and very smart, and that his FIRST thought was for his members.
But nobody suggested that my key point was wrong: while the Chamber positions itself as a small business advocate, it is completely dependent on its insurer relationship for the vast majority of its income. I'm not an economist, but I understand a few things about the "ecology" of Chamber health plans, and one of them is, you work for who pays you. If members' collective dues are $3 million, and your insurance company is paying you another $15 million of your members' money...you work for your insurer.
And if there's a potential for conflict, you're five times as likely to see things your insurer's way as you are to see them your members' way.
Lots of chambers of commerce, trade and professional associations, and other groups are going to be facing a day of reckoning as health insurance reforms are implemented at the state level. Many of these groups sponsor health plans, largely as revenue-generators for the organizations themselves. There are a lot of tricks. Some permit only agents which are organization members to sell the sponsored plans. Most receive hefty marketing and/or sponsorship fees from their sponsoring insurers, which can add up to hundreds of thousands of dollars. Most such plans are not professionally managed by the organizations' staffs.
The result of all these arrangements is all too often that members are being sold a bill of goods, and are seduced into believing that "their" organizations are providing them with good deals, when in reality, their members are being fleeced.
The Chamber I referenced above keeps all information regarding its health plans a secret (and such secrets are rarely in their members' interests). Nobody really knows how many people participate in the plan, what annual premium volume is, what the Chamber's "take" is...and their lawyers will almost certainly pay me a visit if I use their name. So I'll make my point by telling another story.
A few years ago I did a consulting gig for a pretty good-sized regional business organization. The group had about 4,500 member companies; about 2,400 of them participated in the health plans. But the plans weren't growing, and the leadership wanted to know why, and what they could do to improve the plan's performance.
Discovery was a pain. The insurers (there were three) were not co-operative, nor was the broker who ran the plan. But I've been around a little, so I was able to piece the puzzle together.
In every case, when we added up everything coming out of the health plans... commissions, management fees, overrides, and six-figure "sponsorship payments" to the organization...the administrative cost ratio was up to almost 25% of premium before a claim ever got paid. So total administrative costs were in the 30-31% of premium range.
As a consequence, the cost to members of participating in the association's plans was HIGHER than if they'd signed up directly. So members would join, sign up for the health plan for a year, and come renewal time, their agents would move them out of the association's plans at "street rates," which were lower.
When I presented my report to the organization's Board, they were horrified...for the wrong reasons. They were terrified that their members would find out. But they were so dependent on the income they received from the insurers that they couldn't risk "offending them" by actually negotiating with them. So they shelved the report.
Within three years, membership in that association dropped by 40%...and the income it had been receiving from the insurers disappeared as participation in the health plans declined to almost nothing.
A lot of membership groups are in exactly the same boat. They've been jiving their members in order to get paid by their insurers. But with the pressure on insurers to reduce administration costs, those groups are under a lot of pressure to demonstrate, both to their members and to their insurers, how they add value to the equation. Most of them can't.
So they face a Hobson's choice: either they can WAKE UP and recognize the business they're in, have some unpleasant conversations with their members and their insurers, and rebuild their plans, or they can do nothing, and watch their memberships and related income plummet. And in the association business, doing nothing is almost always the strategic choice. So within 3-5 years, they'll be looking at MUCH smaller memberships and MUCH less revenue, and wondering what happened.
Think about YOUR chamber or association. Which choice do you think THEY'LL make?...
Showing posts with label Association Health Plans. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Association Health Plans. Show all posts
Monday, April 25, 2011
Thursday, August 20, 2009
NFIB Nails Small Group Health Reform Priorities In Short Words And Simple Sentences
The National Federation Of Independent Business (NFIB) is the nation's largest small business advocacy organization, with over 600,000 member companies throughout the U.S.
The organization's politics has usually run toward the conservative side. NFIB was one of the organizations often prominently mentioned when talking about the failure of the Clinton Administration's health reform plan.
But this year, NFIB deserves recognition for the clearest and most actionable small group market reform agenda out there in the political process. And the organization has taken to the Net to spread its gospel.
Here's a link to their cover page:http://nfib.matrixgroup.net/tabid/565/Default.aspx?cmsid=49240&v=1 (If the link doesn't work, please copy and paste in to your browser)
NFIB is selling their agenda under three important principles. They're the 3 C's: Cost, Choice and Competition. Here's a summary:
"Cost...We must bring down the cost of health insurance for small businesses and their employees. Currently, they pay 18% more for health care than big businesses. Creating an equal playing field starts with improving the small group insurance markets.
"Choice...Small business owners and employees need more choice when shopping for insurance plans. Health care reform needs to expand the number of providers and affordable plans available to small businesses and their employees.
"Competition...Lack of competition makes it easy for providers and insurers to raise their prices. In many states, small business owners have only one or two choices of insurance providers. A recent study shows that in most states the five largest insurers control 90 percent of the market. We need more competition in the marketplace and access to larger purchasing pools to help lower the cost of insurance for small businesses."
This is a reform agenda to salute. It's concise, well-documented, and recommends action steps which, if enacted, would actually help small businesses control their health care costs. Contrast it to the fuzzy, murky rhetoric coming from other national groups, like the US Chamber of Commerce, The National Small Business Association, and even my COSE alma mater.
But NFIB is in for a fight.
For several years, NFIB has been thinking about the evolution of health insurance toward a national market. They're making a big bet that with their 600,000 member companies, they would be an early favorite to meet the criteria to form a non-profit health insurance exchange or co-operative that could cast a big shadow in the marketplace, and easily move their membership past the one million mark. The organization has developed a health plan for small employers administered by a big broker specializing in association health plans.
The principal impediments: Big local or regional health plan, like Blue Cross Blue Shield plans, who are already the largest insurers of small groups at the local level; and local or statewide Chambers of Commerce and other associations which have used exclusive relationships with these insurers to build their memberships and generate a ton of revenue from sales commissions and other fees.
These groups fear the emergence of national competitors, especially big ones which could negotiate very favorable rates with insurers and providers.
That's why you'll hear them say that, if such co-ops are to be formed, they should be subject to the same rules as insurers, including rules that protect insurers from having to negotiate with associations as big customers on behalf of their members. In effect, they'll demand that any national co-op should be required to be as inefficient as they are.
And that's why I'm cheering for NFIB to win.
The organization's politics has usually run toward the conservative side. NFIB was one of the organizations often prominently mentioned when talking about the failure of the Clinton Administration's health reform plan.
But this year, NFIB deserves recognition for the clearest and most actionable small group market reform agenda out there in the political process. And the organization has taken to the Net to spread its gospel.
Here's a link to their cover page:http://nfib.matrixgroup.net/tabid/565/Default.aspx?cmsid=49240&v=1 (If the link doesn't work, please copy and paste in to your browser)
NFIB is selling their agenda under three important principles. They're the 3 C's: Cost, Choice and Competition. Here's a summary:
"Cost...We must bring down the cost of health insurance for small businesses and their employees. Currently, they pay 18% more for health care than big businesses. Creating an equal playing field starts with improving the small group insurance markets.
"Choice...Small business owners and employees need more choice when shopping for insurance plans. Health care reform needs to expand the number of providers and affordable plans available to small businesses and their employees.
"Competition...Lack of competition makes it easy for providers and insurers to raise their prices. In many states, small business owners have only one or two choices of insurance providers. A recent study shows that in most states the five largest insurers control 90 percent of the market. We need more competition in the marketplace and access to larger purchasing pools to help lower the cost of insurance for small businesses."
This is a reform agenda to salute. It's concise, well-documented, and recommends action steps which, if enacted, would actually help small businesses control their health care costs. Contrast it to the fuzzy, murky rhetoric coming from other national groups, like the US Chamber of Commerce, The National Small Business Association, and even my COSE alma mater.
But NFIB is in for a fight.
For several years, NFIB has been thinking about the evolution of health insurance toward a national market. They're making a big bet that with their 600,000 member companies, they would be an early favorite to meet the criteria to form a non-profit health insurance exchange or co-operative that could cast a big shadow in the marketplace, and easily move their membership past the one million mark. The organization has developed a health plan for small employers administered by a big broker specializing in association health plans.
The principal impediments: Big local or regional health plan, like Blue Cross Blue Shield plans, who are already the largest insurers of small groups at the local level; and local or statewide Chambers of Commerce and other associations which have used exclusive relationships with these insurers to build their memberships and generate a ton of revenue from sales commissions and other fees.
These groups fear the emergence of national competitors, especially big ones which could negotiate very favorable rates with insurers and providers.
That's why you'll hear them say that, if such co-ops are to be formed, they should be subject to the same rules as insurers, including rules that protect insurers from having to negotiate with associations as big customers on behalf of their members. In effect, they'll demand that any national co-op should be required to be as inefficient as they are.
And that's why I'm cheering for NFIB to win.
Sunday, July 26, 2009
Small Businesses Need Health Insurance Reform That Works. Will They Get It? Part 3
So, Mr. President and members of Congress, if you want to take some steps toward fixing small group and individual health insurance, here’s what to do:
1)…Take active steps to encourage the formation of large, non-profit health insurance purchasing co-operatives, and explicitly open them up to small companies and self-employed individuals;
2)…Conduct a top-to-bottom review of the pricing and underwriting rules imposed on the small group and individual health insurance markets by state and federal regulations, and repeal those which do not explicitly contribute to broadening the risk pool;
3)…Establish a series of pilot projects which will encourage insurers to use information technology to increase the efficiency of their small group and individual health plan marketing efforts, and;
4)…Give insurers five years to reduce their administrative cost ratios to not more than 12 percent of premiums for small groups, and not more than 15 percent of premiums for individuals.
The combination of these efforts would create incentives for insurers to work with private aggregators to take advantage of economies of scale to reduce administrative costs, bring down prices, and make health insurance more affordable to more people.
If the marketplace hasn’t improved markedly over a five-year period, a public plan would be enacted, run on principles similar to FEHBP, and administered by insurers who prove they get it.
Absent reforms that look a lot like these, a mandate on individuals or employers would, indeed, force the formation of a public option, because the price of private health insurance will continue to skyrocket, and more small employers and individuals will be priced out of the health insurance market.
1)…Take active steps to encourage the formation of large, non-profit health insurance purchasing co-operatives, and explicitly open them up to small companies and self-employed individuals;
2)…Conduct a top-to-bottom review of the pricing and underwriting rules imposed on the small group and individual health insurance markets by state and federal regulations, and repeal those which do not explicitly contribute to broadening the risk pool;
3)…Establish a series of pilot projects which will encourage insurers to use information technology to increase the efficiency of their small group and individual health plan marketing efforts, and;
4)…Give insurers five years to reduce their administrative cost ratios to not more than 12 percent of premiums for small groups, and not more than 15 percent of premiums for individuals.
The combination of these efforts would create incentives for insurers to work with private aggregators to take advantage of economies of scale to reduce administrative costs, bring down prices, and make health insurance more affordable to more people.
If the marketplace hasn’t improved markedly over a five-year period, a public plan would be enacted, run on principles similar to FEHBP, and administered by insurers who prove they get it.
Absent reforms that look a lot like these, a mandate on individuals or employers would, indeed, force the formation of a public option, because the price of private health insurance will continue to skyrocket, and more small employers and individuals will be priced out of the health insurance market.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
